Eye makeup, mainly mascara, can annoy eyes or skin if it has ingredients that causes allergy or ingredients that you be sensitive to. If you put on contact lenses, the situation can get worse if mascara gets trapped between your lenses and eye, giving you an ouch feeling. So the solution to this problem is the mascaras particularly made for sensitive eyes, which are less likely to irritate when compared to the traditional formulas.
So the question arises that what makes great mascara? The mascaras are normally evaluated on consumer testers, who rate their performance on factors such as ease of application, the volume it is creating, lengthening, curling, and defining/separating effects, and wear ability (flaking/smudging). For waterproof mascaras, a splash test is performed, where mascara is applied by the testers. They wait for good 10 minutes, and then splatter warm water on their face over and over again to judge whether the formula smears or smudges.
What's in this guide?
— How to find mascara that’s harmless for sensitive eyes
When you go to buy your best mascara, search for key terms like hypoallergenic, allergy-tested, or ophthalmologist- or ophthalmologic ally-tested on the packaging of the product. Hypoallergenic shows that the brand has tried to exclude possible allergens that can cause reactions in some people, although it’s not a guarantee that a product is 100% allergy-proofs.
For such kinds, companies generally test the product for allergic reactions or sensitivity on individuals willing to volunteer. Ophthalmologist-tested shows that the testing was supervised by an eye specialist. It is recommended to go for the brands that have a trusted repute for treating sensitive skin and eyes if you have a propensity to experience irritation.
Look at the packaging of mascaras because sometimes they include fragrance on the ingredients list, which can act an irritant, and those that contain natural extracts can act as a trigger for allergies. Go for a waterproof formula if your eyes have a tendency to water; however, be extremely cautious while removing it. Remove it softly without rubbing or tugging to stay away from provoking the eyes and eye area. We have come up with the best hypoallergenic mascaras for sensitive eyes, plus top-reviewed picks, as never compromise performance for tenderness on eyes and skin.
1. Best Volumizing HypoAllegenic Mascara
From the exclusively hypoallergenic beauty brand VMV Hypoallergenic, this volumizing mascara has received high ratings by the consumers. It does not give a burning sensation or throb and gives you massive lashes just after the first application as reviewed by the consumers.
It dries quickly and does not smudge at all during the day.”
2. Best lengthening hypoallergenic mascara
It has received high rating on Amazon; Neutrogena’s lengthening mascara formula is ophthalmologist-tested, plus harmless for sensitive eyes and individuals who wear contact lens. It earned good reviews from many users. This mascara is amazing for long-looking lashes! I would say it as one of the best I’ve ever tried. You are not going to experience any skin reaction or irritation after using it.
3. Easiest-to-remove hypoallergenic mascara
Formulated for simple removal with water, this hypoallergenic and contact lens-safe Maybelline mascara is top-rated for giving a delicately defined effect. If you wear contacts then surely this one is not going to bother you at all. “It delivers a soft, natural look, which is much adored and preferred for every day, with no flaking or clumping.”
4. Best lash-thickening hypoallergenic mascara
From a brand famous for its sensitive skin-friendly formulas, Almay’s hypoallergenic, ophthalmologist-tested, fragrance-free thickening mascara is one of the best-sellers. It will make your eyelashes look thick and full, and it’s hypoallergenic so it’s even mild. If once you will use it you won’t be buying any other brands from now on for sure.
5. Best dramatic mascara for sensitive eyes
One of the most top rated with over 3,500 five-star reviews, Tarte performs it magic to boost volume, length, and give an awesome curl. It is hypoallergenic, ophthalmologist and dermatologist-tested, and harmless for contact lens wearers at the same time. Some people have reviewed it that it gives a look of false lashes. You will for sure love this mascara.
6. Best Clump-Free Hypoallergenic Mascara
CoverGirl’s formula is formulated exclusively for sensitive eyes. It is hypoallergenic and appropriate for contact lens wearers as well. The mascara gives lashes a neat, elegant look that does not experience clumping. Many people have been using this mascara sincelong time as they are almost allergic to everything, except this product. The lashes never experience clumps, the mascara lengthens, separates, and you eyes will never be irritated.
7. Best Mascara For Contact Lens Wearers
This lash-magnifying L’ Oréal mascara is ophthalmologist-tested and perfectly best suited for contact lens wearers and sensitive eyes. It gets removed effortlessly, it is mild and gentle on lashes, and leaves them soft and smooth.
8. Best Hypoallergenic Mascara For Watery Eyes
It is from a brand famous for its sensitive skincare, La Roche-Posay’s is no-smudge formula, is allergy-tested and appropriate for contact lens wearers. It is most preferred as it does not run or smear even after several vigorous repeated exposure to warm water. This has been proved to be the first one that did not smear while crying, sweating or rubbing. It gives enough volume to the eyelashes that eyeliner can be skipped easily.
9. Best Value Mascara For Sensitive Eyes
Ophthalmologic ally-tested, Essence’s magic wand has been a winner and best and most preferred among consumers. It earned top ranking due to the lengthening, volumizing, and curling lashes. Once you will use it will become you new go-to mascara. It gives lashes fuller, longer, and darker look.
10. Best Overall Hypoallergenic Mascara For Sensitive Eyes
This CoverGirl mascara is a hypoallergenic formula. It is one of the best as it earned high for applying on effortlessly, volumizing, lengthening, and separating lashes. The formula even resulted perfectly in water-resistance tests resulting in no smearing, smudging, or running after being splashed with warm H2O. It implies that even if tears come and one cries, the mascara will not go away.
Mascara is an inspiring product that can both lift up your look for a night out and all alone hold it up on a “no-makeup” day. The best mascara adds volume and length to person’s lashes, giving a flabby but natural look. Always remember there’s no one magic number that how many times mascaras needs to be applied on the lashes. Actually, it depends on how intense you would like your coverage to be. If you want a complete, dark, striking look, you might need to give three, four or more coats. Light coverage that is appropriate for everyday use may end with just a single coat. You even need to consider how thick or how runny your mascara formula is. A pro tip is it is better to apply two thin coats instead of one thick coat. This way you will not end up clumping and will have more suppleness about the level of coverage you are going for.